Leica R 50 V1 vs V2: Summicron Comparison & Review

Key Points

• The Leica R 50 V1 and V2 are both excellent lenses, but they cater to different preferences.
• The V1 offers a classic, manual focus experience with a robust metal build.
• The V2 provides modern features like autofocus and a lighter composite body.
• Optical performance seems slightly better in the V2, with sharper images and less flare.
• Your choice likely depends on whether you prioritize tactile feel or modern convenience.

Leica R 50 V1 Vs V2 Comparison

Overview

As a seasoned photographer, I’ve used both the Leica R 50 V1 and V2 lenses extensively. The V1, produced from 1964 to 1976, feels like a piece of history with its solid metal construction. The V2, made from 1976 to 2009, introduces autofocus and a lighter design. Both deliver stunning images, but their differences in build, focusing, and optics make them suited for distinct shooting styles.

Build and Design

The V1’s heavy, matte-finished metal body feels indestructible, ideal for rugged shoots. In contrast, the V2’s glossy composite build is lighter, making it easier to carry all day. The V1’s knurled focus ring offers better grip, while the V2’s smooth ring can feel slippery.

Optical Quality

Both lenses produce sharp, vibrant images, but the V2 edges out slightly. It reduces flare and eliminates the V1’s low-contrast glow when shooting wide open, offering crisper results. The V1’s natural, vivid colors are great for portraits, while the V2’s accurate tones suit technical work.

Focusing and Compatibility

The V1’s manual focus is smooth and precise, perfect for deliberate shooting like street photography. The V2’s fast autofocus excels in dynamic situations, though its manual focus is stiffer. Both lenses work with Leica R8/R9 cameras and can be adapted to modern mirrorless systems like Sony or Canon.

Recommendation

If you love the tactile joy of manual focus and don’t mind extra weight, the V1 is a fantastic choice. For versatility and modern features, the V2 is likely better. I lean toward the V2 for its autofocus in fast-paced shoots, but the V1 remains a beloved classic.

Leica R 50 V1 vs V2: A Photographer’s Deep Dive

Hey there, friends! As a seasoned photographer with over a decade of experience behind the lens, I’ve always been drawn to the magic of Leica cameras. Their ability to capture light and moments with such precision and character is unmatched. Lately, I’ve been wrestling with a choice that many Leica enthusiasts face: should I stick with my trusty Leica R 50 V1 lens or make the switch to the V2? After weeks of hands-on testing and countless hours of research, I’m ready to share my insights with you. In this article, I’ll compare the Leica R 50 V1 vs V2, diving deep into their design, performance, and how they handle in real-world scenarios. Whether you’re a die-hard Leica fan or just curious about these legendary lenses, I hope this helps you make an informed decision.

Let’s get started.

A Brief History of the Leica R Summicron 50mm f/2

Before we dive into the nitty-gritty, let’s set the stage. The Leica R system was launched in 1964 as Leica’s answer to the SLR market, competing with giants like Nikon and Canon (Leica R Lenses Review). The Summicron 50mm f/2 was a cornerstone of this system, designed to be a high-quality standard lens for both professionals and enthusiasts. The V1, produced from 1964 to 1976, was the original version, featuring a robust metal build and a 6-element, 5-group optical design. Then came the V2 in 1976, which stayed in production until 2009. It introduced modern touches like autofocus and a lighter composite body, along with a refined 6-element, 4-group design.

This evolution reflects Leica’s commitment to blending tradition with innovation. Both lenses carry the Summicron legacy, but their differences in build, optics, and functionality make them suited for different shooting styles. Understanding their history helps us appreciate why they’re still cherished today.

Build and Design: A Tale of Two Eras

Let’s talk about how these lenses feel in your hands—because as photographers, we know that build quality matters. The V1 is a beast. It’s made of solid metal, weighing in at 500 grams, with a matte finish that exudes classic charm (A Year with the Leitz Summicron R 50mm F/2 Lens). Its knurled focus ring provides excellent grip, making it easy to adjust focus precisely, even with gloves on. This lens feels like it could survive a war zone—perfect for photographers who demand durability.

On the other hand, the V2 is a product of its time. It uses modern composite materials, tipping the scales at a lighter 450 grams. Its glossy finish gives it a sleek, contemporary look, but that smooth focus ring can feel slippery if your hands are sweaty. The lighter weight is a blessing for long shoots or when you’re carrying multiple lenses, but it doesn’t quite match the V1’s rugged feel.

I’ve taken the V1 on dusty trails and through rainy weddings, and it’s never let me down. The V2, while durable, feels better suited for urban shoots where weight is a concern. It’s a classic versus contemporary vibe—both awesome, just different.

Optical Performance: Where the Magic Happens

Now, let’s get to the heart of what makes these lenses special: their image quality. Both the V1 and V2 are 50mm f/2 lenses, designed for sharpness and versatility. However, their optical designs differ slightly, leading to distinct characteristics.

The V1 delivers excellent sharpness, especially in the center of the frame, with minimal chromatic aberration (Worth the Hype? – Summicron-R 50mm f/2). Its color rendition is natural and vivid, with a warm tone that’s perfect for portraits and landscapes. Wide open at f/2, it has a subtle low-contrast glow that adds a dreamy quality to images—some photographers love this for its vintage charm, while others might find it a bit soft. Stopping down to f/4 or f/5.6 sharpens the edges significantly.

The V2, with its updated 6-element, 4-group design, takes things a step further. It offers enhanced corner sharpness and better control over flare, making it ideal for shooting in bright conditions. The colors are accurate and vibrant, with less fringing than the V1. This lens has a crisper, more modern look, which is great for technical photography or when you need clean, high-contrast images.

I shot a sunset landscape with both lenses. The V1 gave me a warm, almost painterly feel with soft highlights, while the V2 delivered crisp details and controlled flare, making the scene pop with clarity. The V1’s glow can be a creative asset, but the V2’s clarity is hard to beat for precision work.

Focusing: Manual vs. Modern

Focusing is where these lenses truly diverge. The V1 is manual focus only, and it’s a joy to use. The focus ring is smooth and precise, with a tactile feedback that feels almost meditative (50mm f/2 Summicron-R I). It’s perfect for deliberate shooting styles like street photography or studio portraits, where you want full control over your focus. I’ve used it for everything from candid moments to detailed product shots, and it never disappoints.

The V2, however, introduces autofocus—a game-changer for fast-paced situations. It locks onto subjects quickly and accurately, making it ideal for action shots, weddings, or any scenario where you need to keep up with moving subjects. That said, its manual focus ring is stiffer than the V1’s, which can feel less intuitive if you’re used to the buttery smoothness of the older lens.

At a local basketball game, the V2’s autofocus tracked players effortlessly, even in low light. Meanwhile, the V1 required more patience but rewarded me with precise control for slower, more composed shots. It’s a trade-off between control and speed.

Compatibility: Past and Present

Both lenses are designed for the Leica R mount, so they work seamlessly with classic Leica R cameras like the R8 and R9. But here’s the exciting part: with the right adapters, you can use them on modern mirrorless systems like Sony, Canon, or Panasonic (Leica R Adapter L for SL). I’ve personally used both lenses on my Sony A7, and they perform beautifully. There’s no significant vignetting, and the image quality remains stellar.

One caveat: the V2’s autofocus only works on Leica R bodies. When adapted to mirrorless cameras, both lenses revert to manual focus, which levels the playing field. This makes the V1 a surprisingly versatile option for hybrid shooters who mix vintage and modern gear.

I’ve also experimented with using these lenses on Leica M cameras with a Novoflex adapter (Novoflex Adapter). The results were impressive, though you’ll need to account for the 0.5m minimum focus distance, which is closer than some M-mount lenses.

Real-World Shooting Scenarios

Let’s talk about how these lenses perform in everyday use. I’ve put both through their paces in various situations, and here’s what I’ve learned:

• Weddings and Low-Light Events: The V1 shines here. Its manual focus allows for silent operation, which is crucial in quiet venues like churches. The warm, soft rendering adds a romantic touch to portraits and candlelit scenes. I used it at a wedding in a dimly lit chapel, and the images had a timeless quality that the couple adored.
• Sports and Action: The V2 is the clear winner. Its autofocus tracks fast-moving subjects with ease, and the sharper optics ensure every detail is captured crisply. At a soccer match, the V2 kept up with players sprinting across the field, delivering sharp, vibrant shots.
• Street Photography: The V1’s manual focus encourages thoughtful composition, perfect for capturing candid moments with precision. I’ve used it to zone-focus in busy markets, nailing shots without drawing attention. The V2’s speed is handy for grabbing fleeting expressions, but I miss the tactile feel of the V1.
• Portraits: Both lenses excel, but in different ways. The V1’s warm tones and smooth bokeh give a vintage, timeless look, ideal for artistic portraits. The V2’s crisp rendering is better for clients who want a modern, high-definition aesthetic.
• Landscapes: The V1’s natural color rendition and subtle glow create lush, atmospheric images, perfect for moody scenes. The V2’s clarity is great for technical landscapes where you need every detail sharp, like mountain vistas or architectural shots.

Each lens has its stage to shine. The V1 is perfect for slow, deliberate shoots, while the V2 thrives in dynamic, fast-paced environments.

Bokeh and Flare Characteristics

Let’s dive a bit deeper into two critical aspects: bokeh and flare. The V1’s bokeh is smooth and creamy, especially at f/2, thanks to its 6 aperture blades (TT Artisan 50mm F1.2 vs Leica R 50mm F2). It’s ideal for isolating subjects in portraits or creating a dreamy background in nature shots. However, its flare control is weaker—shooting into bright light can result in contrast loss and ghosting, which some photographers use creatively.

The V2, with its updated coatings, handles flare much better. Bright light sources are less likely to cause issues, making it a safer bet for outdoor shoots. Its bokeh is still smooth but slightly less pronounced due to the optical redesign, which prioritizes sharpness over softness.

I tested both lenses during a golden hour shoot. The V1 produced beautiful, glowing flares that added character to my images, while the V2 kept things clean and controlled, perfect for a more polished look.

Video Performance

For videographers, these lenses offer unique advantages. The V1’s manual focus is a dream for precise focus pulls, especially in narrative work where you want full control. Its smooth bokeh and warm tones give footage a cinematic, vintage feel. I’ve used it for short films, and the results are stunning, though you’ll need to be mindful of flare in bright scenes.

The V2’s autofocus is a huge plus for run-and-gun shooting, like documentaries or events. It’s fast and reliable, reducing the need for constant manual adjustments. The sharper optics also make it great for high-resolution video, where every detail matters.

Both lenses have a 20-inch minimum focus distance, which is decent for close-ups but not as tight as some modern lenses. If you’re shooting video on a mirrorless camera, you’ll be using manual focus for both, so the V1’s smoother focus ring gives it a slight edge.

Additional Considerations

A few extra points to keep in mind:

• Lens Hoods: The V1 comes with a metal lens hood that matches its rugged build, while the V2’s plastic hood is lighter but still effective at reducing flare (Leica Summicron-R 50mm f/2 Review).
• Weather Resistance: Neither lens is weather-sealed, but the V1’s metal construction feels more resilient in harsh conditions like rain or dust.
• Resale Value: Leica lenses are investments. The V1, as a classic, may appreciate over time, especially among collectors. The V2 holds strong value due to its modern features and broader appeal.
• Filter Threads: The V1 has a 44mm filter thread, while the V2 uses a 52mm thread, which might affect your filter choices.

Decision-Making Guide: Which One Should You Choose?

So, which lens is right for you? It really depends on your shooting style and priorities. Here’s a breakdown to help you decide:

• Choose the V1 if:
  • You love the tactile experience of manual focus and enjoy the process of deliberate composition.
  • You shoot genres like portraits, landscapes, or street photography where vintage character and warm rendering shine.
  • You’re adapting to a mirrorless camera, where autofocus isn’t a factor, and you want a lens with potential collectible value.
  • You need a lens that can withstand tough conditions without flinching.
• Choose the V2 if:
  • You need autofocus for fast-paced shooting like sports, events, or wildlife, where speed is critical.
  • You prioritize modern sharpness, reduced flare, and accurate color rendition for technical or commercial work.
  • You shoot in bright conditions where flare control is essential.
  • You value a lighter lens for all-day shoots or travel photography.

Personally, I lean toward the V2 for its versatility and autofocus, which I find indispensable for my event and sports work. But I still keep the V1 close for those slow, intentional shoots where I want to connect deeply with my subject. The Leica R 50 V1 vs V2 debate isn’t about which is better—it’s about which fits your creative vision.

Comparison Table

Aspect	Leica R 50 V1	Leica R 50 V2
Material	Metal	Modern composite
Weight	500g	450g
Finish	Matte	Glossy
Focus Ring	Knurled	Smooth
Sharpness	Excellent, minimal chromatic aberration	Enhanced, reduced flare
Color Rendition	Natural, vivid, warm	Accurate, vibrant, neutral
Autofocus	Not available	Available, fast, accurate
Manual Focus	Smooth, precise, tactile	Stiffer, high precision
Build Quality	Solid, robust	Light, durable
Compatibility	Leica R mount, adaptable with adapters	Leica R mount, adaptable with adapters
Lens Hood	Metal	Plastic
Filter Thread	44mm	52mm

Conclusion

The Leica R 50 V1 vs V2 comparison isn’t just about specs—it’s about finding a lens that matches your creative vision. The V1 is a love letter to classic photography, with its solid build and dreamy optics. The V2 embraces modern demands, offering autofocus and crisp performance. Both are stellar lenses, and whichever you choose, you’re getting a piece of Leica’s legendary craftsmanship. So, grab your camera, pick the lens that speaks to you, and start capturing the world in your unique way. Happy shooting, friends!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Can I use the Leica R 50 V1 or V2 on modern mirrorless cameras?

Yes, both the Leica R 50 V1 and V2 can be used on modern mirrorless cameras such as Sony, Canon, or Panasonic systems with the appropriate adapters. However, when adapted to mirrorless cameras, the autofocus feature of the V2 will not function, and both lenses will require manual focus. Adapters are widely available, and many photographers successfully use these vintage lenses on modern setups for their unique optical characteristics and build quality. Compatibility with adapters ensures that these lenses remain relevant for photographers who want to combine vintage charm with modern technology.

2. How does the autofocus perform on the V2 compared to modern lenses?

The autofocus on the Leica R 50 V2, when used on compatible Leica R cameras like the R8 or R9, is functional but not as fast or advanced as the autofocus systems found in modern lenses. Modern lenses, especially those designed for mirrorless cameras, offer much faster and more accurate autofocus, often with additional features like eye detection and subject tracking. The V2’s autofocus is based on older technology, which was advanced for its time but has not kept pace with current advancements. For photographers who prioritize optical quality and are willing to work with slightly slower autofocus, the V2 can still be a great choice, particularly for genres where precise manual focus is also an option.

3. Are there any significant differences in image quality between the V1 and V2?

Yes, there are some differences in image quality between the Leica R 50 V1 and V2. The V2 generally offers better optical performance, with improved sharpness—especially in the corners—and better control over flare and contrast when used wide open. The V1, on the other hand, has a more vintage look with a subtle low-contrast glow that some photographers find appealing for certain types of photography, such as portraits or landscapes where a softer, more romantic aesthetic is desired. Both lenses are excellent, but the choice between them may depend on the specific look and feel you want to achieve in your images.

4. Which lens is better for video shooting?

For video shooting, the choice between the Leica R 50 V1 and V2 depends on your setup and preferences. If you’re using a Leica R camera that supports autofocus, the V2’s autofocus can be beneficial for keeping subjects in focus during video recording, especially in dynamic situations. However, if you’re adapting these lenses to a modern mirrorless camera, both will require manual focus, in which case the V1’s smoother manual focus ring might be preferable for smooth focus pulls. Additionally, both lenses offer excellent optical quality, with the V2 potentially providing slightly better sharpness and flare control, which can be advantageous for video. It’s also worth noting that older lenses like these may exhibit some focus breathing, where the field of view changes as you focus, which can be a consideration for video work.

5. How do these lenses compare to other 50mm lenses from Leica or other brands?

The Leica R 50 V1 and V2 Summicron lenses are part of Leica’s high-quality lens lineup, known for their excellent optical performance. Compared to other Leica 50mm lenses, such as those for the M-mount (e.g., Summicron-M 50mm f/2, Summilux-M 50mm f/1.4), the R-mount lenses are designed for SLR cameras, which means they have different optical designs to account for the mirror box and viewing system. While both M-mount and R-mount lenses offer outstanding image quality, they may render images slightly differently due to these design differences. For example, M-mount lenses are often praised for their high contrast and micro-contrast, while R-mount lenses might have a different character. When compared to 50mm lenses from other brands, such as Zeiss Otus 55mm f/1.4, Nikon 50mm f/1.4G, or Canon 50mm f/1.2L, the Leica lenses are generally more expensive but are highly valued for their build quality, optical excellence, and the unique Leica look that many photographers appreciate.

6. What are the pros and cons of each lens?

Leica R 50 V1:

• Pros:
  • Robust metal build, feels indestructible
  • Smooth, precise manual focus
  • Classic, vintage look with warm, vivid colors
  • Excellent for deliberate shooting styles like street photography or portraits
• Cons:
  • Heavier weight (500g)
  • No autofocus
  • Slightly more prone to flare when shooting wide open

Leica R 50 V2:

• Pros:
  • Lighter weight (450g)
  • Autofocus capability on Leica R cameras
  • Sharper images with better flare control
  • Modern design with composite body
• Cons:
  • Glossy finish might be less grippy
  • Stiffer manual focus ring
  • Less of the vintage character compared to V1

7. Is it worth upgrading from the V1 to the V2?

Whether it’s worth upgrading from the V1 to the V2 depends on your specific needs and preferences. If you value the autofocus capability and the slightly better optical performance of the V2, and you are using a Leica R camera that supports autofocus, then upgrading might be beneficial. However, if you prefer the manual focus experience, the vintage look, and don’t mind the heavier weight of the V1, you might not need to upgrade. Both lenses are excellent, and the choice ultimately comes down to whether the additional features and improvements of the V2 are important enough to justify the upgrade for you.

8. How do I maintain these lenses to ensure they last?

To maintain your Leica R 50 V1 or V2 lenses and ensure they last, follow these care tips:

• Cleaning: Use a soft, lint-free cloth for the exterior. For the glass, use a lens cleaning solution and a microfiber cloth, avoiding direct contact with your fingers.
• Storage: Keep the lenses in a dry, cool place, preferably in their original cases or lens pouches to protect from dust and moisture. Use silica gel packets to absorb moisture if storing for long periods.
• Avoid Extremes: Protect the lenses from extreme temperatures, humidity, and physical shock.
• Regular Inspection: Periodically check for signs of fungus, haze, or mechanical issues, especially if the lenses have been stored unused for a long time.
• Mechanism Care: If the focus or aperture rings become stiff, consider applying a small amount of lens grease, but do so sparingly and carefully.
• Handling: Handle the lenses with care, especially the V2 with its composite body, which may be more susceptible to scratches.